Hong Kong: will protests spread to mainland?

Protesters are rejecting what they call Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam’s “fake concession,” with the demonstrations now in their fourteenth straight week. Contrary to widespread media reports, Lam’s supposed  “withdrawal” of the extradition bill is actually only a promise to withdraw it when the Legislative Council reconvenes next month—with no date yet set. Lam refused the other four demands of the current unprecedented mass movement: repudatiation of the term “riots” for the protests (with “riot” charges carrying a 10-year prison term); an independent investigation into police brutality during the demonstrations; release of all detained protesters, and the dropping of all charges; and “universal suffrage” in elections of the chief executive and Legislative Council.  (Nikkei Asian Review, The Villager)

ChinaWorker.info, a Hong Kong-based website that supports independent labor struggles in China and is now supporting the protest movement in the city, warned of a replay of events in Wukan, a village in Guangdong province that saw a local uprising in 2011, only to be outmaneuvered in the end by the regime:

Fake concessions accompanied by repression are a trick the Chinese dictatorship (CCP) has always used. In the Wukan struggle in Guangdong province in 2011, the villagers who struggled against police brutality, land theft, and for the democratic election of village officials, mistakenly believed the CCP’s promise about allowing elections and so called off their struggle. Eventually the CCP-state took grim revenge with the breaking of all promises, mass arrests, and a fierce crackdown.

What the CCP most fears is showing weakness towards Hong Kong protesters, which will damage the dictatorship’s authority and in turn inspire the mainland masses to rise up and fight, following the example of Hong Kong masses. In that case, Hong Kong’s revolution can be spread throughout China in a chain reaction. Therefore, after Lam’s withdrawal of the bill, the CCP intends to launch violent repression in Hong Kong in order to prevent the potential spread of the movement to mainland China.

Many of the protesters, however, are not looking to fellow protesters in mainland China as allies, but to Western imperialism. The US media (NBC, CNN, NYT) are jumping all over an incident today in which thousands of protesters waving US flags marched on Hong Kong’s US Consulate to call for help from the White House. Some sang the “Star-Spangled Banner” and carried a large banner reading “PRESIDENT TRUMP, PLEASE LIBERATE HONG KONG.”

This is extremely maddening news. Surely these protesters are aware of Trump’s open glorification of police repression of protesters. Apart from displaying incredible naivete about US intentions, such stunts play right into Beijing’s propaganda that the Hong Kong protests are all fomented by Western imperialism. We certainly hope such incidents are receiving disproportionate hype in the Western media (and recall that up to a million have participated in the Hong Kong protests, so even a protest of several thousand is not necessarily representative of the whole movement). We’d like to hear less from the Hong Kong protesters appealing to Trump and more about solidarity (for instance) with the protests that broke out in Wuhan, in central China, in the midst of the Hong Kong uprising.

That kind of solidarity is what could really threaten the China’s party-state dictatorship. Rallying around Trump doesn’t threaten it at all. It strengthens it.

Photo: ChinaWorker.info

  1. Encouraging anarchist graffiti in Hong Kong
    A Facebook page entitled Radical Graffiti displays some very encouraging slogans spray-painted on to walls in Hong Kong in recent days, apparently by anarchist elements among the protesters. One, seemingly on the wall of a subway station, shows the circle-A symbol alongside the slogans “CCP IS CAPITALIST” and “CAPITALISM IS SHIT!!!”

    Another reads: “CHINAZI + AMERIKKKA, 2 COUNTRIES 1 SYSTEM.” However juvenile the “Chinazi” and “Amerikka” may be, the “2 countries, 1 system” line displays perfect acumen: an ironic play on the supposed “one country, two systems” arrangement between Hong Kong and China, it makes the point that supposed imperial rivals China and the US are equally capitalist.

    More of this.

  2. Hong Kong: robbery at Socialist Action office
    Hong Kong’s Socialist Action, publishers of the incisive and courageous ChinaWorker.info, suffered a break-in at their office, with six computers stolen. Socialist Action is one of the few groups involved in the Hong Kong protest movement to emphasize solidarity with workers’ struggles in mainland China, and this break-in was almost certainly politically motivated. Please support them if you can.

  3. Advances for HK pro-democracy forces
    Hong Kong’s pro-democracy camp has won a majority of seats in the District Council – the first time it has done so since the 1997 Handover. The Nov. 24 elections also delivered a stinging rebuke to the pro-Beijing camp, which saw some of its most prominent leaders defeated. (HKFP) Days later, Trump signed the Hong Kong Human Rights & Democracy Act, and the Protect Hong Kong Act—both of which passed Congress with broad bipartisan support. The first authorizes sanctions on Chinese and Hong Kong officials responsible for human rights abuses, while the second bans the export to Hong Kong police of US-made crowd control munitions such as tear gas, stun guns and rubber bullets. (CNN)

    We’ve noted before that such US-made matĂ©riel is winding up in the hands of the Hong Kong police, and it is impossible not to support this legislation. But we do worry that it will further entrech the unseemly Trumpophilia displayed by the Hong Kong protesters.

  4. Yes, protests spread to mainland…
    Protests broke out Nov. 29 in the town of Wenlou, in Huazhou prefecture of Guangdong province—just 60 miles from Hong Kong. Riot police used tear-gas and deployed armored vehicles, and arreested some 100. At issue was planned construction of a crematorium in the town, which had been disguised as an “ecological park.” The project has now reportedly been cancelled, but protests are continuing. (SCMP, The Guardian)

    Stay tuned.