Oriana Fallaci, exponent of “left” Islamophobia, dies at 77

The political trajectory of Oriana Fallaci speaks to one of the funamental political dilemmas on the planet at this strange juncture. The daughter of an Italian anti-fascist militant, a veteran Vietnam war correspondent, a survivor of the 1968 Tlatelolco massacre in Mexico, longtime lover of a martyred opponent of the Greek military dictatorship—she nonetheless joined the anti-Islam and anti-immigration chorus after 9-11. While large sections of what we call the “idiot left” rush into an “anti-imperialist” alliance with political Islam, others (especially in Europe) rush into the equally unsavory xenophobe and Islamophobe camp in the name of defending secularism and feminism. From The Guardian, Sept. 15:

Controversial Italian journalist dies
Oriana Fallaci, Italy’s best-known journalist, whose diatribes against Islam following the September 11 attacks on America won her global notoriety, has died. She was 77 years old.

Unknown to all but her closest friends and relatives, Ms Fallaci had returned from her home in New York to her native Florence. A statement from the Santa Chiara clinic in Florence said she had been admitted “some days ago” and died in the early hours of this morning. She had been suffering from cancer for more than 10 years.

Italy’s popular former president, Carlo Azeglio Ciampi, added his considerable moral authority to the tributes that poured in, mostly from rightwing politicians. Mr Ciampi said the writer’s life was one of courage, struggle “an example for all”.

That judgment will not be shared by all his compatriots, many of whom expressed disgust at the obscenity-spattered invectives against immigration and Muslims that made her a bestselling author in the final years of her life.

Courage, nevertheless, was a hallmark of Ms Fallaci’s life. She was born the daughter of an anti-fascist cabinet-maker who involved her in the Resistance struggle waged by Italian partisans against German occupation after Italy’s withdrawal from the second world war.

At the age of 10, she was already carrying messages and, later, arms. She was honoured for her role at the end of the conflict.

After the war, Oriana Fallaci became a journalist and, in the early 1950s, joined the staff of the magazine L’Europeo. The veteran reporter and commentator, Giorgio Bocca, who also worked for the magazine, remembered her for “a combination of vitality and boorishness”.

It was as a roving correspondent for L’Europeo that she covered the Vietnam war and several other conflicts. Yet the closest she came to death was probably in 1968 when, before the start of the Mexico City Summer Olympics of that year, she was caught up in a massacre by security forces of students and other protestors.

Ms Fallaci was shot and left for dead. She would have been put into a morgue had an attendant not noticed she was still breathing.

What won her, first, national, and then international renown, though, was her uniquely aggressive interviewing style. Each savage dissection of a leading public figure only encouraged the next to try to pit his or her wits against the daunting Italian.

Among those who submitted to her questions were Yasser Arafat, the late Shah of Iran, Indira Gandhi, Golda Meir, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Muammar Ghaddafi. Henry Kissinger bitterly regretted having done so after Ms Fallaci lured him into comparing himself with a lone cowboy riding ahead of a wagon train.

Arguably her most famous encounter was with the Ayatollah Khomenei in whose presence she threw off the chador she had been obliged to wear. Though her gesture led to the interview being suspended abruptly, the founder of Iran’s Islamic revolution subsequently, and astonishingly, agreed to resume it and, according to Ms Fallaci’s account, ended up laughing out loud at her unrepentant effrontery.

Oriana Fallaci never married, but she did have a long and tumultuous affair with the Greek poet and politician, Alexandros Panagoulis, an opponent of the rightwing military junta that ruled Greece from 1967 to 1974. His life and death, which Ms Fallaci believed was murder – inspired her 1979 novel Un Uomo (A Man).

As an author, Ms Fallaci consistently enjoyed better sales than critical appreciation. She yearned to be taken seriously as a novelist, but it was a quite different work, her Letter to a child never born, published in 1977 after a miscarriage, that won her the greatest critical praise.

By the time she stopped writing in the early 1990s, after being diagnosed with breast cancer, Oriana Fallaci was widely considered as a left-leaning liberal, albeit one with some idiosyncratic opinions. One was her evident and burning dislike for most of the Muslims she had encountered on her travels.

That prejudice was to come surging to the surface after 9/11 when, on September 29 2001, she broke her long silence with a 14,000 word harangue that appeared on the front page of Italy’s bestselling daily, Corriere della Sera. The article became a book, La rabbia e l’orgoglio, that was a runaway bestseller in Italy and was soon put into translation (in English, as The Rage and the Pride).

She subsequently published two further works elaborating on the same basic message that Muslims were bent on imposing their religion on the rest of the world, and that their migration to Europe was gradually but inexorably preparing the way for its transformation into “Eurabia”. These ideas made her an idol for the xenophobic, anti-immigrant Northern League, but they also recommended her to many Italians and other Europeans who felt she was articulating their deepest fears.

Her three most recent books sold more than four million copies worldwide. They earned her, among other things, a rare private meeting last year with the Pope.

It is strangely apt that Oriana Fallaci’s tempestuous life should have ebbed away just as the Pope himself was becoming embroiled in a passionate controversy over his own views on Islam.

See also WW4 REPORT #30.

See also our last posts on Italy and Islamophobia.

  1. Telling quotes
    These two excerpts from the New York Times obituary say much about Fallaci’s descent from principled opposition to political Islam to mere ugly xenophobia of the lowest order.

    “How do you swim in a chador?” she asked Ayatollah Khomeni in 1979, not long after he came to power in Iran…


    Saying that the “sons of Allah breed like rats,” she strongly condemned the growing immigration of Muslims in Europe, including her native Italy.