Malaysia: three women caned for adultery

For the first time, Malaysian authorities have caned three Muslim women under Islamic law for acts of adultery, the country’s national news agency Bernama reported Feb. 17. Home Minister Hishamuddin Hussein said the punishment was carried out Feb. 9 at a women’s prison near Kuala Lumpur, “to educate and make the offenders realize their mistakes and to return to the right path.”

“It is hoped that the issue will not be wrongly interpreted to the extent of tarnishing the sanctity of Islam,” Hussein was quoted as saying, adding that the punishment did not cause any injury and that the women were remorseful and repented, Bernama reported.

Malaysia has a dual justice system, in which Islamic courts operate alongside civil ones. Muslims make up about 60% of the country’s population of 28 million. In a case that sparked a national outrage last year, a woman was sentenced to caning under Islamic law for drinking alcohol in public—beer at a hotel bar. Malaysia forbids alcohol consumption by Muslims, even those just visiting the country.

The caning sentence of Kartika Sari Dewi Shukarno has been postponed while the issue is under review. She says that if she is to be caned, she wants it to occur in public. “Let’s be transparent about it,” said Kartika, a mother and part-time model. An Islamic court also fined her $1,400 for the act. She pleaded guilty and paid the fine.

The canings were denounced by Amnesty International official Lance Lattig as “tantamount to torture,” saying the group considers the practice to be “cruel, inhumane and degrading.” Amnesty said there is an “epidemic” of caning for minor offenses—mostly immigration violations—in Malaysia. According to Lattig, some 35,000 people have been caned in Malaysia since 2002. (Radio Australia, Feb. 19; CNN, Feb. 17)

See our last posts on Malaysia and the struggle within Islam

Please leave a tip or answer the Exit Poll.

  1. Towards a righteous civilisation
    The wisdom of Malaysian Islamic faith is for the offender of such immoral acts to be caned and only then will the offender repent and not repeat their immoral acts. This mindset must be instil in every muslim of the world and as such the world should learn from us as this form of punishment will leads to a more moral s…ociety and towards achieving and producing a more righteous civilisation.

    1. Whatever, dude
      One man’s “righteous civilisation” is another’s “tantamount to torture.” We’re with Amnesty International on this one, thank you.

  2. Caned for lesbian sex in Malaysia

    Two women convicted of "attempting to have lesbian sex" in a car were ordered caned by a religious court in Malaysia, the BBC reported Sept. 3. The account, citing local media, said "caning under Islamic law is not similar to caning carried out for crimes under civil law. It is not meant to cause pain." Oh? Presumably it is not mean to cause pleasure….