Norway’s Supreme Court on Nov. 13 upheld a lower court ruling invalidating the government’s approvals for three North Sea oil and gas projects. The court held that the government had failed to assess the climate impact of emissions from the burning of the hydrocarbons from the projects, alongside emissions from other existing and approved projects on Norway’s continental shelf.
The high ourt unanimously held that the EU Environmental Impact Assessment Directive, as implemented in Norwegian law, requires authorities to assess emissions from burning of the oil and gas before approving development plans. The original assessments covered emissions from developing and operating the fields. The government later assessed emissions from burning the hydrocarbons, but the court ruled 6-5 that those assessments were inadequate because they omitted the cumulative emissions from other projects.
The ruling covers the Breidablikk and Tyrving fields and the Yggdrasil bloc, which comprises three fields. The Ministry of Energy must now reconsider the approvals. The oil companies were not parties to the case, and the ruling does not require operations to stop while the ministry reassesses the projects.
Greenpeace Nordic and Young Friends of the Earth Norway brought the challenge. Haldis Tjeldflaat Helle, Greenpeace Nordic’s Norway representative, called the ruling “a momentous victory for global climate justice.”
Under its 2035 commitment under the Paris Agreement, Norway aims to cut greenhouse gas emissions by at least 70-to-75% from 1990 levels.
From JURIST, Nov. 16. Used with permission.
Photo: Banja-Frans Mulder via Wikimedia Commons




